11 Points

11 Unusual (and Way Over-the-Top) Thanksgiving Desserts Around the U.S.
written by Sam Greenspan

Tomorrow night, my family and I will sit down and have pumpkin pie for dessert. Apparently, that makes US the weirdos.

There was a great unpretentious feature on the New York Times website yesterday ("What are sentences never before uttered, Alex?") about unusual Thanksgiving foods that are popular in different states around the U.S. I'd never heard of most of the things listed but wow -- they all sound glorious. I thought this country was supposed to be a melting pot. Why haven't any of these things melted onto me?

The results of this study are based on which foods and recipes were Googled in each state around Thanksgiving more often than any other time of the year. The Google results span the past decade, so all of these foods have some legit staying power.

Here are 11 unusual (and over-the-top) Thanksgiving desserts that are popular in various states and regions of the U.S.
  1. Frog Eye Salad (popular in Colorado, Idaho, Nevada, Utah, Wyoming)

    The word "salad" is going to be used VERY liberally throughout the course of this list, and frog eye salad kicks off that trend in an unapologetic way. Frog eye salad is like an Americanized ambrosia salad -- a combination of pasta, canned pineapple, canned mandarin oranges, eggs, Cool Whip, coconut and marshmallows.

  2. Strawberry Pretzel Salad (popular in Alabama, Delaware, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Nebraska, Wyoming)

    This is a dessert (and hopefully not the "fruit" option at dinner) that seems to be something of a Flaming Homer situation -- someone seemingly created this while just combining a bunch of stuff in the house and saying, "Voila, dessert." It features a pretzel-based bottom layer, a cream cheese and Cool Whip middle layer, and strawberry Jell-O on top. Maybe some real strawberries on top too, although that's optional.

  3. Key Lime Cake (popular in Georgia)

    I don't love key lime pie, but key lime cake looks incredible to me. I also give credit to Georgia for claiming this one and not just conceding all things key lime to Florida.

  4. Pumpkin Crunch (popular in Hawaii)

    Hawaii always likes to do its own thing, different than the rest of the country -- like binging on spam and having beautiful weather -- so this fits in well. People in Hawaii search for "pumpkin crunch" 145 times more than people in any other state. It seems like a basic (and quite possibly better) alternative to pumpkin pie -- basically a mix of yellow cake and pumpkin filling.

  5. Snickers Salad (popular in Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, South Dakota, Wisconsin)

    How did I make it more than three decades in America (two of those in the Midwest) without ever learning about this before? It's one of the few recipes I could actually make. Snickers salad is, quite simply, chopped up Snickers bars mixed in Cool Whip. Many recipes also tell you to toss in some diced green apples, even though those just sound like empty vitamins.

  6. Cookie Salad (popular in Minnesota and North Dakota)

    If you just read about Snickers salad and thought it sounded a little too nutritious -- what with the inadvertent health benefit of the peanuts -- direct your attention here. This is a mix of cookies, pudding, and, of course, Cool Whip. Cool Whip is in like two-thirds of these, man.

  7. Dirt Pudding (popular in Indiana and Ohio)

    I grew up in Ohio, have spent well above 90 percent of my Thanksgivings in Ohio, am currently in Ohio... and have never had dirt pudding at Thanksgiving. (Or any other time, actually. Maybe it's more of a rural Ohio thing? Damn you, cosmopolitan nature of the Cleveland suburbs.) Dirt pudding is a mix of vanilla (or chocolate) pudding, milk, sugar, cream cheese, butter, Cool Whip and a bunch of crushed Oreos. Or Hydrox, if you're contrary. You can even put gummy worms in to really enhance the "dirt" motif.

    (While I've never eaten dirt pudding, I did have another Ohio dessert as a kid that could be its cousin -- trash bag delights. We'd put Crispix cereal in a bag with powdered sugar and melted chocolate chips and shake it up.)

  8. Sopapilla Cheesecake (popular in Oklahoma and Texas)

    Sopapilla cheesecake is to authentic Mexican sopapillas what Taco Bell is to authentic Mexican everything else. It's a cheesecake that's baked inside of crescent rolls. (Side note: The only time I've had real sopapillas was at Casa Bonita, almost exclusively on the recommendation of Eric Cartman.)

  9. Pineapple Casserole (popular in Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina)

    The ingredients (according to Paula Deen, naturally) are one cup sugar, six tablespoons flour, two cups grated sharp cheddar, two cans of pineapple chunks, six tablespoons of pineapple juice, at least one stick of butter and "1 cup cracker crumbs (recommended: Ritz)." I feel like pineapple casserole is like an adapted version of kugel created by like four Jews trying to assimilate into the South.

  10. Butterfinger Cake (popular in Alabama, Kentucky, Tennessee)

    Have people been baking with candy bars all this time and nobody told me? Based on the rest of this list, you can basically extrapolate the recipe for Butterfinger cake. Cake mix, Butterfingers, Cool Whip and you're good.

  11. Pumpkin Whoopie Pie (popular in Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Vermont)

    In most situations, putting a mix of cream cheese, sugar, butter and vanilla between two pumpkin cookies would seem indulgent. But like 1,000 miles away people are putting Snickers bars into a tub of whipped cream and calling it a "salad," so this seems downright reserved.

This post was originally published on Wednesday, November 26, 2014 at 11:00:00 AM under the category Food & Drink.

11 Things College Freshman Should Expect During That First Thanksgiving Back Home

11 Great Moments In People Taking Their Fast Food Passion Too Far

11 Most Dangerous Holidays for Driving

11 Manliest Alcoholic Drinks Ever

The 11 Worst-Tasting Beers in America (According to Statistics, and According to Me)

Archive of all Food & Drink posts
11 Songs That Just List Off a Whole Bunch of Cities
11 Songs That Just List Off a Whole Bunch of Cities
Published Friday, May 19, 2017 at 11:00:00 AM under the category Music
11 Coincidental Wardrobe Choices That are Evidence of Cosmic Intervention
11 Coincidental Wardrobe Choices That are Evidence of Cosmic Intervention
Published Wednesday, May 10, 2017 at 11:00:00 AM under the category Misc
11 Pieces of Advice For Anyone Cutting the Cord
11 Pieces of Advice For Anyone Cutting the Cord
Published Tuesday, May 2, 2017 at 11:00:00 AM under the category TV
11 Foods That Were Engineered To Be Instagrammed
11 Foods That Were Engineered To Be Instagrammed
Published Tuesday, April 25, 2017 at 11:00:00 AM under the category Food & Drink
11 Great Moments in Pedantic Graffiti
11 Great Moments in Pedantic Graffiti
Published Friday, April 14, 2017 at 11:00:00 AM under the category Travel
All 30 MLB Teams' Official Hashtags, Ranked From Bad to Worse
All 30 MLB Teams' Official Hashtags, Ranked From Bad to Worse
Published Monday, April 3, 2017 at 11:00:00 AM under the category Sports
Full Archive
11 Points

Mailing list